logoalt Hacker News

egypturnash • yesterday at 11:03 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

How about protecting assets for the people who made the art in the first place, geeze.

And seriously wtf why shouldn't, like, Jack Kirby's grandkids get a share of the huge bounty of stuff he created for Marvel, but Elon Musk gets to inherit emerald mines from his dad?


Replies

_carbyau_ • today at 2:09 AM

You two are arguing over a timeframe.

Limit IP laws to 20 years.

Humans go from birth to being released into the public domain as an adult in roughly that time. Why are ideas somehow not in the Public Domain after a generation has grown up?

That way Jack Kirby gets to make his money. Jack's kids can live off his money. But Jack's ideas are free to use after doing their time.

mr_toad • yesterday at 11:49 PM

IP has very low marginal cost, emeralds don’t.