logoalt Hacker News

-1 • today at 2:44 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

Replace every instance of "PRC" with "U.S.", DeepSeek with OpenAI/Anthropic, and replace "U.S." with any other nation, and maybe remove the last sentence. How does it sound now? Both nations may as well just say it - "we're banning it because they're our closest competitor".


Replies

nater5000 • today at 5:00 PM

>How does it sound now?

It sounds logical and sound? As a US citizen, I (a) agree that we shouldn't be allowing government employees to use AI services from adversary foreign governments and (b) that other countries shouldn't be allowing their government employees to use AI services from adversary foreign governments (which the US should be considered for plenty of countries).

>Both nations may as well just say it - "we're banning it because they're our closest competitor".

I guess we're just ignoring the national security implications lol

grumple • today at 11:19 AM

If I were China, I would ban US models from being used by my government for the same reasons.

nashashmi • today at 4:12 AM

The difference is that local US companies have agency to refuse government overreach while Chinese companies are weaker in this regard. Chinese companies are more vulnerable to its govts pressure.

➕ show 3 replies