logoalt Hacker News

nish__ • yesterday at 3:33 PM • 6 replies • view on HN

How have our democracies not abolished copyright law yet? These laws only serve the 1%. I have no idea why we still put up with them.


Replies

numpad0 • yesterday at 3:58 PM

FOSS depends on copyright laws. Oldest versions of Linux and UNIX are more than 20 years old, so early versions of both would be hypothetically now in public domain in the absence of Disney-lobbied maximalist versions of copyright laws, or in the total absence of one.

➕ show 3 replies
immibis2 • yesterday at 7:10 PM

There was a recent attempt to substantially reform copyright in the EU - it was called "Stop Killing Games". It gathered over one million signatures, forcing the EU parliament to consider it. Their response was "this would require us to change copyright law, and we can't do that, sorry."

The USA strong-arms copyright law into every single trade deal. I think it was Chile who tried to strike DMCA 1201 out of some trade deal with the US about food staples, but were swiftly informed by the US that if they didn't make DMCA 1201 into Chilean domestic law, the US would completely cut off their trade. This stuff is serious business for the US and no other country is in the geopolitical position right now to question it.

Fortunately since the US is mid-collapse that last point may change soon.

https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/28/disenshittification-natio...

dist-epoch • yesterday at 4:01 PM

How do you feel about OpenAI training on all of the books in the world.

➕ show 4 replies
slopinthebag • yesterday at 8:40 PM

because people have been successfully propagandised into believing it to be necessary or good. of course they argue for it without any evidence.

bigstrat2003 • yesterday at 5:54 PM

> How have our democracies not abolished copyright law yet? These laws only serve the 1%.

I don't think that claim is true, personally. But if we grant it for the sake of argument, it should be completely unsurprising that copyright hasn't been abolished. Governments primarily serve the powerful and wealthy, not the common man.

cyanmagenta • yesterday at 3:38 PM

> How have our democracies not abolished copyright law yet? These laws only serve the 1%

Yeah, fuck those billionaire authors and artists in coffee shops not wanting people to rip off the books and art they create without compensation.

➕ show 5 replies