logoalt Hacker News

zaphirplane • yesterday at 10:34 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

False dichotomy?

Ignoring smaller crimes just because they're under $1,000 isn't the answer. things can quickly spiral. How many times do you wake up to your car scratched window broken or whatever and would be ok ?


Replies

michaelt • yesterday at 11:08 PM

> False dichotomy?

Yes, I'm trying to say it's a false dichotomy. There are plenty of other ways you could organise a justice system, many of which would lead to more just results.

For example - a fixed price system. 8 hours wages from the two parties to the dispute buys 30 minutes with one judge and two lawyers. More than enough time to deal with a minor matter like a scratched car. Or if you prefer a continental-style inquisitorial system, you can lose the lawyers and have 90 minutes with a judge. The fees mean judges and lawyers take home 5x the average salary.

➕ show 1 reply
codebje • yesterday at 11:15 PM

How often do you get that sort of crime attended to and resolved satisfactorily?

tomkarho • today at 5:08 AM

California's got this experiment going I believe.