logoalt Hacker News

Copenjin • today at 6:02 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

This obsession with Rust is very hard to understand


Replies

brabel • today at 6:30 AM

Yeah but the post criticized Go for a project like Docker, so it makes sense to ask what else could have been used. At the time there weren’t many system languages fit for the purpose.

thephyber • today at 6:19 AM

It's not hard to understand. It's just not rational to anyone who actually calculates how performant it is (very fast, I agree) with how long it takes to write.

Once I realized how difficult it is to write complex code that actually satisfies the borrow checker, I was perfectly happy with writing somewhat slower code in Go or Python.

➕ show 1 reply
pjmlp • today at 6:27 AM

The obsession isn't with Rust, the obsession is with Go not being a good programming language and the only reason it took off was thanks to Docker.

So they would probably never rewrite from Python into C or C++, because not cool, too hard kind of motivation, otherwise they would not have picked Go.

So that begs the question, if the obession as you call it, was already a thing back then, would Rust have been the lucky candidate?

➕ show 2 replies