logoalt Hacker News

Sigma Says the Compact, Modular FP2 Is the Ultimate Hybrid Camera

49 points • by thm • last Friday at 4:41 PM • 75 comments • view on HN

Comments

freetime2 • yesterday at 9:14 PM

I looked into buying a compact full-frame camera a couple years ago (the Sony a7c2), and came to the conclusion that the size and weight of lenses matters more than the camera body. So personally I don’t really see the point of making a camera body this small if you have to sacrifice on things like IBIS, an EVF, physical controls, and heat dissipation/recording limits.

Are there any particular use cases where a camera this small really offers a significant benefit? Perhaps street photography when paired with certain compact lenses? Or mounted on a gimbal?

Or maybe the L mount and compact size would make this an appealing secondary camera for people who already own L mount lenses for Panasonic or Leica (as well as some DJI and Blackmagic) cameras?

➕ show 6 replies
9x39 • today at 5:29 AM

Cautiously optimistic for them. Sigma faces some steep competition against Canon/Sony/Nikon but might be able to find a niche like Fuji has with price on one hand and lens+color fans on the other.

No IBIS is rough, because its definitely a useful thing - the R6 III has 8.5 stops for $2.7k, same price as the FP2 with an EVF. At $2.2k, the partial stacked sensor might reduce the jello effect, might not. It's an interesting tradeoff and it'll come down to whether the AF is good enough to make the 20 fps it shoots at usable. For example, if you shoot 30 fps but the AF doesn't work, 28/30 shots being blurry is a waste. The flagship cameras can get 60-90% keep rates if you do your part, so I'm curious what Sigma's system can pull off outside of a studio.

I think the biggest problem with a minimalist ILC is that a commodity body stops making sense bc once you throw in even a few decent lenses and the usual other spend on memory and lights, you're outside of the budget range. You don't _have_ to have Art lenses and nice gear - one of my favorite fun lenses is a $150 lensbaby experiment, but the gap between a decently rounded Canon kit and a Sigma kit closes in price and widens in capability fast once you get started, at least gear-wise.

xuhu • yesterday at 9:56 PM

How do people who are far sighted use cameras without EVF ? When I have to hold a camera 20 cm in front of me to film I just pretend I'm able to focus on the LCD.

➕ show 1 reply
robotmay • today at 12:01 AM

Sigma are far and away my favourite photographic company right now, for a variety of reasons, but top of the list has to be that they're doing something different. What they're doing might not be for you but at least they're not just making another camera the same shape as every DSLR/mirrorless camera going back 25 years.

From a personal perspective, they were the only company that was interested in loaning me gear to review from right at the start of me making YouTube videos. Many other companies continue to refuse to talk with me even when I've found serious bugs.

The frustrating part is that they're currently not releasing full-frame lenses on Nikon's Z mount, likely due to a licensing issue with Nikon. And that's frustrating because for my needs, there's no "pro" level camera on L mount that I can use, and Sony hobble third party lens manufacturers' maximum burst speeds (also I don't like Sony's AF but that's another story). I ended up selling a lot of my L mount gear and consolidating on Nikon for professional work.

But I did buy myself a Sigma Bf. The Fp series is excellent but the Bf is beautiful. It's such a fundamentally weird camera that it reminds me of camera design back in the 60s-90s where companies went absolutely nuts with camera ideas. Is it my most practical camera? Very much not. Is it the camera I use to take pictures of my cat? Absolutely.

I'm always excited to see what Sigma comes out with. Their optics and manufacturing have moved on dramatically since Yamaki-san took over in 2012, and they're constantly bringing out really interesting new optics. I'm very excited to try out that new 50mm f/1.4 CL they announced, personally.

I highly recommend watching videos on the ProcessX YouTube channel that shows their factory and processes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qx14Juo4AQo.

Aurornis • yesterday at 9:18 PM

I like this concept of a minimal core camera which has a huge sensor, the logic board, a battery compartment, and then mounting points for accessories to customize it to the use case.

Lack of in body image stabilization is difficult, though. It makes sense for a minimum size camera but IBIS is amazing when it’s working well.

➕ show 1 reply
steveBK123 • today at 12:36 AM

Sigma is the last great experimenter in the industry and I appreciate everything they do however wacky (former fp, fpL and various i-series lens owner)

aftbit • yesterday at 8:50 PM

I would imagine you'd need at least FP16, if not a full FP32, to get the ultimate camera.

➕ show 1 reply
MattCruikshank • yesterday at 8:54 PM

I'm surprised there aren't Android Cameras? At a reasonable-ish price?

Like a Pixel 6a is $249 new right now.

So, where's that same caliber of hardware, but as a camera-first?

➕ show 5 replies
Stevvo • today at 3:22 AM

Pointless having a camera so small if you need a tripod everywhere because it has no image stabilization.

➕ show 4 replies
smlacy • yesterday at 8:01 PM

Cool looking camera, but OMG this website is HORRID. Brings my entire computer to a crawl, barely can scroll the article at all.

➕ show 3 replies
cyberax • yesterday at 9:35 PM

Still no GPS. What's WRONG with you, camera makers?

➕ show 1 reply
morfredus • yesterday at 10:02 PM

Why not but.. No grip, with a zoom it can become complicated to hold the whole thing properly. And at what price? On the other hand, regarding miniaturization, it’s a success.

➕ show 1 reply
abletonlive • today at 3:12 AM

I'm done w/ hybrid cameras. Just make a video focused camera or a photography focused camera. Didn't people learn their lesson after seeing how well FX3 did?

kylehotchkiss • today at 5:39 AM

oops, I breathed on my camera and that flimsy screen just broke off

manoDev • today at 1:54 AM

Good thing Sigma is moving forward with this concept, FP was close to being a cult camera if not for some flaws.

mvid • yesterday at 8:08 PM

Odd to have a modern camera released without photo signing

➕ show 5 replies
esafak • yesterday at 9:32 PM

Nice,nice. Is this a Foveon design?

➕ show 2 replies