logoalt Hacker News

armchairhacker • today at 12:47 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

Maybe a hot take, but I think that example is fine. Less verbose than “the form is submitted” and there’s no ambiguity, it’s the English analogue to `form.submit()`.

In your other comment, “Talking also costs.”, it’s clarified through context that talking costs tokens.

I think it’s a side-effect of the AI companies trying to reduce verbosity and redundancy, which were my personal main complaints with LLM writing. Though I believe LLMs are still verbose, and I suspect it’s because they don’t know what to remove, and these are cheap gains where the LLM removes verbosity that is obvious but expected because everyone does it.


Replies

prmph • today at 8:52 AM

No, it is not more clear.

What is happening is this: the AI does not know when to be a more verbose in service of clarity, and when to be brief, again in service of clarity. There is no simple relationship between expression length and clarity; it all depends. And when they are verbose, it is usually a lot of words that actually say little.

That's the problem; there is some higher level reasoning they are incapable of when it comes to language usage.