logoalt Hacker News

hasley • today at 6:42 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

I am sorry for that. Fortunately, this does not resemble my experience (electrical engineering/digital signal processing).

Usually I got quite critical comments (positive and/or negative). Yes, sometimes a reviewer does not write even a single sentence before giving an average score to complete the review process. But this has not been the regular case.

And as a reviewer for a conference paper of 4 to 6 pages, I usually assigned 1 to 3 hours to read it (journal papers: 1 to 2 days) and to give comments.