logoalt Hacker News

mwkaufma • yesterday at 5:32 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

The poison-pill requirements had their intended effect: https://discuss.python.org/t/an-announcement-from-the-steeri...

It would have been more honest to just cut the feature instead of haranguing a developer until they withdrew it.


Replies

12_throw_away • yesterday at 5:40 PM

I mean, if your multi-year-old project is ever asked to just take a moment to write out a quick formal roadmap and justification ... it is doomed, 100% of the time. The actual content of the request doesn't really matter, it's dead.

To be clear, such a request doesn't even mean that someone is consciously attempting to kill the project (although in the corporate world, ime it probably does). It just means that something went critically wrong. In this case, it appears like python's development process really required a PEP for this sort of work, especially since it was happening on the main branch.

➕ show 2 replies