logoalt Hacker News

Freedom2 • yesterday at 5:43 PM • 8 replies • view on HN

I disagree. The US has the 1st and 2nd amendments, which gives us protection from tyranny in the government, and which lets us criticize the government without repercussion. No other country grants its citizens those rights, and you can see the effects of that worldwide, where despite it all, we still have our free speech!


Replies

quantified • yesterday at 7:17 PM

How does the 2nd amendment protect you? Are you allowed automatic weapons, grenades? You're not even allowed swords. And if you call for violence, which is what the 2nd amendment might enable, you won't find protection via the 1st amendment.

See citizens and ICE.

➕ show 2 replies
BeetleB • yesterday at 8:21 PM

Whatever one may think of gun control, it's clear the 2nd Amendment is on a much poorer footing.

In a number of states, you need to take a safety course before you're allowed to purchase a gun.

Compare that with the 1st amendment. If they passed laws saying "You can say whatever you want in public, but only after you've taken this course that informs you on what is acceptable and unacceptable to say in public", would you say there is free speech?

Or "You are free to practice any religion, but only after you've taken a course that ..."?

➕ show 3 replies
platevoltage • yesterday at 10:34 PM

You can't possibly be this naive.

➕ show 1 reply
vrganj • yesterday at 7:35 PM

That is a wonderfully naive understanding of the world.

You should ask Alex Pretti how he was able to criticize to criticize the government without repercussion.

➕ show 1 reply
stldev • yesterday at 6:48 PM

Can you name a single western democracy where the citizens are prohibited from criticizing their government?

➕ show 1 reply
protocolture • today at 4:02 AM

>The US has the 1st and 2nd amendments, which gives us protection from tyranny in the government

Lmao. Jim Tyranny has had what? 3 cracks at him? Hardly protection.