logoalt Hacker News

majorchord • yesterday at 8:13 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

IMO This is an even more naive (and dare I say intentionally malicious) bad-faith misinterpretation of the facts.

His death had nothing to do with the Constitution, it was because of a trigger-happy, confused cop who had his back to the guy, then noticed a gun next to him (that another officer previously put there). The US government had no part in that situation at all.


Replies

cowlevel • yesterday at 9:28 PM

I think that's exactly the point. The constitution didn't prevent his death.

What are cops if they're not the government? Are they private corporations?

➕ show 1 reply
nullstyle • yesterday at 9:03 PM

The US government is responsible for the training of its agents. It is culpable as well.

vrganj • today at 1:33 AM

That's kind of the point.

The constitution is just some rules people wrote up generations ago. It's not a magic spell that has power by itself, it is only effective as a social contract as long as power structures agree to follow it.

If armed government enforcers break it with impunity, what good is it?

platevoltage • yesterday at 10:35 PM

If you can't exercise your rights without being murdered by a state sanctioned thug, then it's not really a right. Also, has he been indicted yet? charged?