logoalt Hacker News

pedalpete • yesterday at 10:22 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Look at the first image with the people in the field. That looks to me like a very poorly generated image, not a real image of people, and not even a high-quality AI generated image.

Is this what we can expect of the new apple? I'm not against AI generated imagery, but I expect them to be of equal quality to a real photo.

Or am I wrong, and it isn't AI generated?

The things that make me think it is just poorly made are 1) the angles of the laptop on the black case, 2) the lack of any lighting on the back panel, 3) the size of the hand on the woman in the back, and the squareness of what she is holding (if it is even supposed to be another mac).


Replies

neom • yesterday at 11:31 PM

Almost certainly not AI gen, it's shot with a 35mm lens (quality looks like the 1.4 L to me), probably around f8 given how the DOF falloff happens, heavy forward flood (flash or otherwise, but whatever it was it's defused) and then what's I think giving you the sense it's AI is it looks like they've over used a double S curve to bump the contrast and sharpness. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZh_9HnO_4w&t=640s

boesboes • today at 7:38 AM

I’m more confused by the scene itself. Why are they in a field? What are they doing?

jodrellblank • yesterday at 11:25 PM

That was my first thought, is that guy's face AI? The angle of the laptop looks off. Then I decided I don't care and moved on, but yeah, you're not the only one who thought it looked off.

iLoveOncall • yesterday at 11:58 PM

It's just a very bad picture, but every detail is perfectly coherent, it's not AI generated.

Still a baffling choice.