logoalt Hacker News

agwa • yesterday at 12:42 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Google, Microsoft, Mozilla, several TLS libraries and language runtimes, and even many Linux distros run by volunteers had this issue comprehensively fixed over a week ago: https://emudhra.we-have-a-problem.com/#developers

Meanwhile, it's unsafe to run `git clone` on macOS unless you manually edit some files, and then edit them again after a macOS update puts the dangerous root certificates back.

In what world has Apple been the most "thorough"?


Replies

LoganDark • yesterday at 12:53 PM

Apple has been the most thorough in documenting this transparently and honestly. They didn't have the process for updating that file in the wild, and most likely that will be fixed.

Apple security updates, especially automatic ones, likely don't have the capability to simply write to arbitrary files on the system or run arbitrary commands at install time. Of all vendors, certainly from Apple I'd expect this.

Most likely, other vendors either already used a similar store as the root of trust system-wide (didn't have their own separate security stacks), or their security updates do have the ability to write anywhere or do anything.

And of course, Linux distros and other platforms where the component can be updated separately from the operating system have an even easier time.

This is not Apple intentionally leaving terminal users high and dry. The article literally is the proof otherwise while they no-doubt work on a better solution.

➕ show 5 replies