logoalt Hacker News

WindyTree • yesterday at 8:38 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

Who could have done that role but Stewart? Take the guy who played Riker or anyone else in that role and you would have lost the flavor. He will be missed.


Replies

hnlmorg • yesterday at 9:07 PM

He wasn’t Gene Roddenberrys first choice. In fact he had to get talked into casting Patrick Stewart by the other execs.

Roddenberry was after someone younger. There’s even a casting show reel of Stewart wearing a toupee and speaking with a very bad French accent.

➕ show 1 reply
pimeys • yesterday at 8:46 PM

Although Frakes is close to a god in my books as an actor and a director. But never a good captain in TNG, I agree. He's a loved director though, and part of many great Star Trek episodes, and a few good ones for The Orville.

➕ show 1 reply
somerandomqaguy • yesterday at 10:31 PM

If we're talking modern day? Edward James Olmos channelling Commander Adama would probably be a very close 2nd if not outstanding on it's own. I could potentially see Scott Glenn pulling it off but that one's a touch iffy IMO.

➕ show 1 reply