logoalt Hacker News

ndsipa_pomu • today at 10:30 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

> America's poor today have clean water, health care

Clean water depends on how you define "clean" e.g. from https://www.theglobalstatistics.com/united-states-water-poll...

> Current EPA data reveals that nearly half of all tap water in the United States contains detectable levels of PFAS chemicals

There's also plenty of contamination violations (apart from maybe Hawaii with only 2) of the water supply.

As far as health care goes, I thought that most people in the USA will refuse to get an ambulance due to the expense. I've also heard of plenty of reports that poor people will not visit a doctor for minor health issues even though they may be early signs of much more serious issues.


Replies

WalterBright • today at 6:13 PM

The king's "doctors" in medieval times were little more than witch doctors.

> Clean water depends on how you define "clean"

Always, back to arguing about the definitions of words. Let's put it simply. People before 1800 had little idea about clean water. They didn't know what bacteria was. They didn't know about contaminants. They had very poor sanitation practices. They died of cholera regularly.

Probably the greatest advance in health care in history was the introduction of a clean water supply.

So if you want to quibble about what "clean" means, I'll take municipal water, water filters, and boiling any day over what anybody in medieval times drank. If you don't think your water is clean enough, get a water filter from Amazon. They're cheap, and they work.

In the US, emergency rooms cannot turn away anyone. The care delivered there is light years ahead of anything any king got in medieval times.