logoalt Hacker News

vintermann • today at 4:28 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

I agree with everything in this article, but there are a few things that make me go hmm.

* The reference to / advertisement of obscure online communities (Agor? Darkworld?)

* The quoted tweet about bloodlines. There are no lines worth speaking of in biology, there are webs. You are not the last one in a very long line, you're a twig on a very big tree. People who talk about their bloodline are often a bit iffy.

So why do I make an issue of it, when I agree with everything they say anyway? Because I actually agree with a lot of what lots of weird sects say - in public. The advertising pitch is often very reasonable even for groups like Mormons or Scientologists, which are 50-250 years out of touch with the trends of the times. This post is very sensible, but it feels like a pitch for something which isn't quite as easy a sell. Maybe this Agor thing.


Replies

orlp • today at 4:50 PM

> The quoted tweet about bloodlines. There are no lines worth speaking of in biology, there are webs. You are not the last one in a very long line, you're a twig on a very big tree. People who talk about their bloodline are often a bit iffy.

A fun thought exposing the silliness: every woman without a daughter is the end of a chain of mothers going back millions of years.

butlike • today at 4:46 PM

As an only child being the "last of my bloodline" has given me a great deal of anxiety. Evidently out of ignorance. Where can I learn about lineage being more of a web than a line?

➕ show 4 replies
akramachamarei • today at 5:48 PM

In other words, is your issue with the usage of the term that it mistakes a set of O(2^n) bloodlines for 1?

nonethewiser • today at 5:06 PM

Webs are made of lines. A twig has a path back to the root. And you are only a leaf node until you reproduce, after which you are a branch and perhaps a shared part of this “web.”

coldtea • today at 5:33 PM

>People who talk about their bloodline are often a bit iffy.

On the other hand though, people who don't are often as an aggregate group destroying a lot of twigs to the detriment of the tree, all the while pretending their love the tree in general that's why they don't care for their twig.