logoalt Hacker News

pjmlp • yesterday at 9:16 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

That is fighting the last war on the early days of 5 GLs, and taken care by agentic runtimes.

This isn't futurology, besides a few projects that already came up on Phoronix and around here, with Assembly generation, there are enough SIGPLAN papers on ML driven compilers already.


Replies

bayindirh • today at 9:57 AM

ML driven compilers are different than LLM assembly generation, and former is more sound than the latter one. I believe we both have enough experience to understand that.

However, starting with LLMs directly generating machine code and moving to ML directed optimization passes, you're moving the whole stadium with a crawler-transporter, not only the goalposts.

Helping compiler in a well defined way, and working on IR or driving it repeatedly to optimize the output is one thing, generating machine code from a training set is other. Let's not mix them.

➕ show 1 reply
anthk • today at 3:28 AM

Like inform7 but irreproducible and shitter on every iteration.

➕ show 1 reply