logoalt Hacker News

empath75 • today at 5:26 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

If you leave "The Honest Summary" in anything Claude wrote, I am not going to read any of it, shows a complete lack of care or interest in what you are doing.

I don't care if you are having Claude write something for you, but I feel like I spent more time writing these two sentences than this person put into this post.


Replies

scubbo • today at 6:35 PM

My opinion has shifted over the last few months. Instead of valuing effort put into "putting words together", I am trying to judge the value that I get _from_ the words[0].

I'm reminded of a passage in Stephen Fry's "The Liar"[1], which draws the distinction between a book as an object of art, and a book as a vehicle for communication. If the message is worthwhile, I don't care if it was blurted out by a model or if blind monks inscribed it by hand into vellum parchment.

Don't get me wrong, there's certainly correlation - if I _know_ you've taken a lot of effort to write something, the chances are good that there is worthwhile content being communicated. But the correlation is _not_ perfect.

[0] when it comes to technical writing that intends to communicate information. Narrative writing that intends to evoke an emotion or viewpoint is a different story!

[1] https://blog.scubbo.org/posts/books-as-vehicles/

➕ show 1 reply