logoalt Hacker News

motoroco • yesterday at 10:17 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Claude code writes adds a `User-Agent` request header like `my-session-slug/1 <[email protected]>` when searching the web and requesting data. This violates the privacy of paying customers and has resulted in me getting dozens of scam and phishing emails per day from properties I have never personally visited. This policy is asinine: it does nothing but harm me, the customer, while providing immense value for scrapers and scammers.


Replies

tcoff91 • yesterday at 10:39 PM

Wow... this is insane! What a terrible idea.

These are the exact kinds of things that a human engineer would almost certainly never do.

This kind of thing is the problem of going all in on the idea of the AI Software Factory.

➕ show 1 reply
3abiton • yesterday at 10:49 PM

I don't know if this is an anti-abuse method they are using or some weird promotion for claude? It genuinely makes no sense from a user perspective.

➕ show 2 replies
TZubiri • yesterday at 11:05 PM

The reason they do this is because otherwise they block the requests.

I'm not sure what the issue is with publishing your email address in principle, you are reaching out, you want to inquire about some business. If anything use a different address. But why would you asymmetrically expect businesses with websites to bend over to give you all the advantages, they need some assurances as well.

Anonimity usually works one way, one party can be anonymous, not both, if you come from consumer land, it's the companies exposing themselves and doing all the compliance, if you choose privacy and force the companies to expose themselves, you'll get your wish granted, but there will be a cost, it's unlikely you'll be in the more advantageous position.

➕ show 2 replies
Seattle3503 • yesterday at 10:47 PM

Do you think this was a human choice, or one of those subtle Claude choices you don't notice until it bites you?

I'm sure the answer will be to update AGENTS.md to not do this particular thing, expose email in this way, which isn't the same as having sense.

➕ show 1 reply