logoalt Hacker News

dotancohen • yesterday at 9:22 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

So the EV still beats the ICE vehicle threefold (2 units vs 6 units), it just _feels_ worse (half as efficient as without a trailer) so you declare it _is_ worse.

With that type of reasoning, let me guess, the competitor you work for is General Motors?


Replies

nextaccountic • yesterday at 9:32 PM

EV beats ICE in isolation but without just as much charging stations as petrol stations the advantage is theoretical. Also you need faster charging too (I heard BYD latest tech can do this, can Tesla just license?)

A federal law could easily fix this though, but you would need an administration that cares about climate change or at least about EV

➕ show 1 reply
hansvm • yesterday at 9:43 PM

Efficiency was brought up to explain the real problem, range. I didn't fill up between Reno and SF in my F350 towing a massive trailer and still had plenty of fuel to spare. A cybertruck would've barely made it past Sacramento with a much lighter load and would've taken much longer to fill up.

➕ show 1 reply
kraig911 • yesterday at 10:01 PM

IMO it is worse. And I thought I said where i worked in my original comment. You just can't get the range to work on EV's and towing (my personal opinion) large pickups have big gas tanks and it's quick and easy to fill up. It's all about ergonomics. Yes an EV with a full battery vs a ICE with a full tank EV will always be more 'efficient' but day to day it doesn't add up.

Ergonomics and ease of use are why people get cars. Ergnomics right now to me are reason why EV's in America don't sell well. Infrastructure. If every apartment complex and shopping mall had chargers or we had a novel way to charge a battery like an ICE engine then yeah it will take off. Culturally though I think we just love gas stations, emissions and pollusion.

➕ show 1 reply
cwel • yesterday at 9:33 PM

They put the competitor they work for in their comment, it was not edited, it was there when you posted this reply.

Excellent sleuthing, either way.

➕ show 1 reply