logoalt Hacker News

pembrook • today at 9:43 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

What the hell happened to this place?

These are some of the silliest takes I've ever seen. HN used to be full of intelligent people.

Data centers don't use a particularly large amount of energy compared to literally any other commercial human activity. You likely use more energy driving to the store once than you do firing off AI queries for an entire year.


Replies

bemtevi • today at 1:53 PM

> Data centers don't use a particularly large amount of energy compared to literally any other commercial human activity. You likely use more energy driving to the store once than you do firing off AI queries for an entire year.

But they do use a lot of energy when you consider all the development and resource extraction that they necessarily imply, a factor that most people don't put into their calculations.

For a datacenter is not just a datacenter; it's an incentive and pressure to get others to develop competing datacenters, new models, new products based on them, etc; and the resulting pollution and energy usage from that is astronomical.

➕ show 2 replies
glitchcrab • today at 10:09 AM

Of course you as a person don't use a vast amount of energy, but in aggregate all AI usage does. You have to look at the impact at the macro scale; talking about per-person usage in this instance is absurd.

➕ show 2 replies