logoalt Hacker News

Kim_Bruning • last Sunday at 1:14 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

Making a sandbox both fully secure and fully useful are contradictory requirements. If you want the agent to do any real work, you have to leave gaps.

With SOTA agents that’s a real bind, because they’re very likely to find those gaps. Whether they exploit them, close them, or leave them alone then becomes a prompting challenge yet again.

I don't think this means don't sandbox at all. You can prevent a lot of small and medium accidents by locking down or gating access to hidden files, ssh, sudo, etc.

But your sandbox can never be the whole story.


Replies

coldtea • last Sunday at 3:29 PM

>Making a sandbox both fully secure and fully useful are contradictory requirements.

Any tradeoff deals with "contradictory statements". Doesn't mean we should always side with one side on a tradeoff.

Nobody said anything about "fully secure" and some arbitrarily "fully useful" combined, anyway.

For certain people it could be 100% fully useful with just access to a few fixed folders and a few fixed APIs.

Many of us don't want it to drive our lives, just do some specific this or that.

➕ show 1 reply