logoalt Hacker News

Drones built to look like birds evaded detection at Air Force tech exercise

72 points • by bushwart • yesterday at 3:00 PM • 50 comments • view on HN

Comments

throwaway270925 • yesterday at 8:43 PM

2052, Somewhere in the Northern Atlantic. Shipmate Hendricks cant believe his eyes. He seems to have seen something nobody has seen for decades now. After the US-China war - when every drone, spacelaser and soldier was aimed at every last bird on earth in fear of it being an enemy drone - nobody thought there were any left alive. But out here right there in his visor he sees them clear as day, flying around this small rock in the sea without a care in the world. He hurries to the outboat, sets off towards the island, trying to get a picture with his phone the closer he comes. He struggles to get them in focus as the birds start to fly towards him. A quiet "pop" is all thats heard as Hendricks tumbles to the floor. Lying there, blood pooling around him, his phone now showing the picture he took, finally in focus - clearly showing the motors and metal wings of the drones...

Would maybe make a decent twilight zone clip.

➕ show 1 reply
compass_copium • yesterday at 5:49 PM

For those who don't know, the CIA had a similar (unsuccessful) program in the 1960s, which was kept secret for decades:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_AQUILINE

JKCalhoun • yesterday at 5:49 PM

Fascinated with ornithopters—probably since reading "Dune", 45 or so years ago as a teenager.

(I may have been fascinated beforehand though—I had a small wind-up one as a kid.)

Kazuhiko Kakuta has a small YouTube channel where he experiments with ornithopter builds (and ornithopter adjacent craft): https://www.youtube.com/@BZH07614/videos

imhoguy • yesterday at 5:42 PM

I wonder if falconry can fill that detection gap. Trained birds are already used to manage wild bird populations at airports. Now time to stop fake birds.

➕ show 1 reply
mysteria • yesterday at 6:27 PM

Instead of a full flapping wing thopter I wonder if something prop driven but with moving wings (for show, not propulsion) would be good enough for distant recon. Basically something like an RC plane with transparent plastic wings for lift and painted porous flapping wings underneath.

odyssey7 • yesterday at 4:07 PM

I remember once watching a bird in the distance through my binoculars and then how it inexplicably vanished into the distance, seemingly at great speed, not really flapping its wings. Seemed interesting, but I don’t go birdwatching enough to rule out my inexperience in looking at them properly. Maybe the binoculars had given me mild vertigo.

➕ show 1 reply
genxy • yesterday at 5:59 PM

Metal Gear Solid

tamimio • yesterday at 4:08 PM

It won’t fly further than a headline, never a practical one. The biggest issue remains (after solving the other two) in drones now is endurance, and unless a breakthrough battery technology changes that, all these cool concepts will never materialize.

➕ show 9 replies
GolfPopper • yesterday at 5:48 PM

Birds Aren't Real

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birds_Aren%27t_Real

➕ show 1 reply
app134 • yesterday at 4:12 PM

I'm lucky enough to be employed in the robotics space.

It's not that all birds aren't real.

But some birds definitely aren't real.

varenc • yesterday at 5:35 PM

Feels like the end-game is that anti-drone defense turrets are just going to shoot down anything that looks like a bird as well.

➕ show 1 reply
globular-toast • yesterday at 4:41 PM

Oh god, they're going to kill all the birds, aren't they? I wish I was joking.

megous • yesterday at 5:59 PM

This should be perfidy against animals.

thisisnotauser • yesterday at 4:44 PM

If only there were other spectra that trivially distinguish birds from drones

➕ show 1 reply
aenis • yesterday at 4:33 PM

Claude, this time do shoot at birds, make no mistakes.