logoalt Hacker News

real_faxenoff • yesterday at 4:31 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I became interested in how the harness works internally so I could try to implement my own small AI agent in a business project. And I realized that right now, most of the model’s efficiency lies precisely in the harness. And that there’s a whole complicated world inside it, one that will soon become more complex than the models themselves.

All my experiments using third-party harnesses for code-writing agents showed that if a model is used in a non-native harness, it sometimes burns through 5 times as many tokens, and the results are worse. That’s why I now use MCP calls not to the models directly, but to new sessions within their harnesses.

Now, almost every day I see new announcements about coding agents with bold claims about their superiority. But in none of them have I seen a clear description of how they’re better or exactly how their architecture for working with models is superior to the original harnesses.

As I understand it, Pi is like "Lego" for building your own harness. But do you know what happened after I’d been using real Lego for half a year? I have 15 kg of it loose in three bags. My son and I have almost given up on the idea of sorting it out and actually using it properly. It’s pretty much the same story with my MCP, plugins, and skills for Claude.


Replies

bloppe • yesterday at 10:38 PM

Non trivial software projects of course require a bit more organization than most kids will devote to their legos. The ideal solution is to keep your software small and simple so you barely need to think about organization, but if you can't keep it small and simple, then you better not let it turn into a 15kg bag.

Pi is much smaller and simpler than cc, and it's a finished product, not necessarily DIY "legos". You don't have to build plugins for it, and many people say it's superior to CC / codex / OpenCode out of the box. If you do want to build plugins, it already provides you with a well organized system to build around.

yxhuvud • yesterday at 7:16 PM

Sorting lego? What. Just build stuff, why would you sort it.

➕ show 1 reply