logoalt Hacker News

schiffern • today at 9:27 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

  >The line in the chronicle stating, "Uruk was defeated," may refer to a military conquest, but could as easily mean that it lost its position of leadership 
Interesting (but not surprising?) that semantic drift has been with us since the beginning of language.

A word that once meant "succeeded in time" can shift in usage over a few scant generations (and motivated, "my side winning is as inevitable as the passage of time" rhetoric) to eventually become a synonym with "defeated in battle."


Replies

Bluestein • today at 9:41 AM

Indeed. I mean, the Mother of all Drifts comes with the entire logographic system shifting to accommodate more and more meanings, and abstract concepts ...

... enough to support a flourishing civilization (several) over thousands of years.-

Also, the parallels with today (power, war, "leadership" ...), "our highways are covered with weed and no wine nor syrup flows forth ..." are considerable.-

➕ show 2 replies