logoalt Hacker News

jcattle • today at 1:48 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

This statement is baffling to me.

1. Wikipedia is not wikihow. It is not an aim of wikipedia to teach you how to tie a knot.

2. Youtube does not reward or otherwise provide provenance and incremental improvement.

Look at the revision page for the windsor knot: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Half-Windsor_knot...

There is no mechanism whatsoever on youtube to incrementally improve a video or understanding of a topic.


Replies

joenot443 • today at 3:11 PM

> There is no mechanism whatsoever on youtube to incrementally improve a video or understanding of a topic.

Yes there is? You've been able to trim and append end screens for years. Usually when understanding on a topic changes people upload newer videos.

Do you expect the books on your shelf to update every year? What a baffling relationship with media you must have.

> Youtube does not reward or otherwise provide provenance and incremental improvement.

I don't think that Wikipedia rewards provenance either? The "reward" seems to be seeing your own beliefs put to text. I suppose that's what you're getting at?