logoalt Hacker News

stavros • today at 3:18 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Because I want to open source my software AND don't want it used commercially. What's the problem? I just use the AGPL and that's that.


Replies

basilikum • today at 4:14 PM

The AGPL does not prevent commercial neither as a user nor as a publisher of the software. It even prevents anyone from creating a derivative work from your software and publishing it under a license that prohibits commercial use.

Someone can absolutely fork your software and use it commercially. That's what FOSS is about: You shall not limit what other people can do with the software.

You may however restrict others from putting restrictions on derivative works of your software. That's what the GPL is all about. You enforce reciprocity and ensure that all works based on your software allow the user the essential freedoms of free software.

➕ show 1 reply
dmantis • today at 4:11 PM

AGPL doesn't prohibit commercial usage. The vendor just need to provide the sources for the service.