logoalt Hacker News

ultimatefan1 • yesterday at 1:12 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Good article! The initial headlines from a few days ago made it seem like frontier models were becoming able to read, understand, and manipulate weights directly. This seemed unlikely to me since they aren’t trained on weights, they’re trained on tokens and task completion (RL). This analysis makes me think a better description is that Astra did some interesting model training research that included running small experiments with altering weights and found a nice edit that fixes some problems. Cool, also cool that this analysis finds a faster approach. But a far cry from the headlines when the paper first came out.


Replies

FrustratedMonky • yesterday at 1:42 PM

It seems a little like splitting hairs.

Astra didn't directly edit the weights, it came up with a method to edit the weigths?

So, it used another tool to edit the weights?

This kind of seems like saying, I don't directly edit the bits on my hard drive, thus i'm not really the one saving a file?

➕ show 3 replies