logoalt Hacker News

CharlieDigital • yesterday at 8:30 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I looked, but you're mistaking my critique here: I value polish.

This lacks polish.

Small details like getting your GH repo set up for a public audience. Lacking. Compatibility and support matrix clearly advertised? None.

If this public facing artifact exhibits a lack of care and love, what does it say about the code? I am all for vibe coding and agent software factories, but then the humans should show some love with all of that extra time saved.


Replies

simgoh • yesterday at 8:33 PM

You might want to reconsider how you present the critique then, because that's not how your root comment came across or any of your subsequent messages, especially when engaging with (presumably) actual AWS employees in this thread replying to you.

➕ show 1 reply
hluska • yesterday at 9:59 PM

If your complaint is about polish, you’re a very poor writer. It should not have taken this many replies to get that point out. But regardless of your communications skills, I disagree - this product looks fine for something released at this stage.