logoalt Hacker News

scarecrowbob • today at 12:14 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

I mostly agree with this.

Like, I know what a secondary dominant is because I've had to use it in blues turn arounds- I didn't know that's what some folks would call it, but I knew that in the key of G, I'd often play an A instead of the Am.

And I think that the vocabulary should describe what folks do rather than the doings being driven by the vocabulary.

Most guitar players (and improv folks) that I know have much more theory that the folks who are reading but who generally don't think about what the function of their line is in a larger song.

If you're playing by memory and ear, you have to have some concepts because you can't just read a part.

Those concepts -are- the theory.


Replies

javier123454321 • today at 12:54 PM

Yeah there's just a badge of honor to say that you don't know theory, as though it's something bad if you do, for some people, for some reason