logoalt Hacker News

kodoman • today at 10:23 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

> Why?

The thing with the whole systemd hate thing is everyone now knows why people might hate systemd (I am not a fan). I think a lot of features around isolation and systemd containers where useful but now probably using your containerization system that best suits your needs.

For me when I get really mad at it is when I want to build small nixos Images and want to minimize the footprint of systemd and run few services (some of that is on nixos as well).

I think it's better suited for desktop systems then server systems and it's quite annoying how prevalent it is. D-bus is one thing that always annoys me and how everything in systemd wants to use it and you can run into issues disabling it (Also don't like D-bus even on a desktop system).

Overall I think and hope we will see a rise not necessarily in openrc but in simpler init 1 systems that try to do less and provide good strong primitives that allow for easily using what ever daemon configured how you want, rather then trying to provide coupled implementations for everything.

Again I know these criticism are something of a meme, but they still are true.