logoalt Hacker News

greggsy • today at 11:47 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

Curious to hear why they did this to begin with.

I can understand the warranty aspect: they don’t necessarily want to be in the hook when users stuffs up the port using a janky 20-in-1 USB-C hub.

Why play around with the VRR and HDR side of things too?

Edit: I know someone will say ‘because they want to sell more docks’, but it already comes with the console… the market for people buying multiple docks I doesn’t justify the development and manufacturing costs.


Replies

pletnes • today at 12:28 PM

Every single laptop vendor deals with this. Ipads, desktops, you name it. Nintendo are simply not anywhere near industry baseline here.

➕ show 1 reply
ramses0 • today at 12:30 PM

IMHO, their USB-C-ish is frustrating. Same shape but not all chargers work. But on the flip side, understand what they're doing.

Nintendo is not making a USB-C computer, they're making a _product_ or a cohesive system.

They do not want you plugging in an arbitrary charger (which may not have the right wattage), don't want you laying the switch face up (nubs on the controllers getting in the way), face down (scratching the screen), plugging in a usb-c controller and dragging the spiderweb of wires off the entertainment center, or trying to use the touch screen while attached to a TV.

They wanted a vertical dock that managed airflow, charged at the appropriate rate, and guided you away from asking why you couldn't have some janky setup where you're trying to treat it like a gameboy advance (local screen simultaneous to big TV) being held by kindergarteners who pull the TV off the stand).

...so the dock is effectively a sacrificial buffer/safety system to prevent your switch from causing damage to your TV.

➕ show 2 replies
mystifyingpoi • today at 12:56 PM

Because they are Nintendo, that's why.

DS Lite famously had a silly proprietary connector for charging, which required their special wall charger... which was literally a 5V charger. It could have been mini/micro USB from the beginning, but no.

Raed667 • today at 11:52 AM

> doesn’t justify the development and manufacturing costs

At Nintendo scale, I bet it does though

➕ show 1 reply