logoalt Hacker News

patcon • today at 1:39 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

> Except evolution does really exist without life.

Biochemist and OoL enthusiast here. This is very not true. Evolution happens in even the simplest complex systems. It's very likely a process of matter.

Look up the work of Dr Michael Levin. He shares on YouTube many of his convos with leading thinkers. He's quite prolific lately.


Replies

pfdietz • today at 1:51 PM

Unless you have highly accurate replication, selection is limited in the amount of information it can accumulate. 90% accurate replication gives you ~10 bits of information. Much beyond that and information is erased faster than selection can create it.

So I strongly dispute your assertion there.

sandworm101 • today at 1:49 PM

Evolution as in change from one state to another, but is that change from natural selection? I suspect it is change based on chemistry without inherited traits. A mountain can evolve through natural processes from a lump of fresh rock to a complex structure of peaks and valleys, but a mountain does not pass those traits along to offspring. So there is no natural selection driving the evolution of mountains.