logoalt Hacker News

TFNA • yesterday at 5:58 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Within linguistics, there is a small but respected body of research on these children born to Esperantist parents, and the term "native speaker" is commonly employed (though even for natural languages that term is problematic, so "L1 speaker" might be preferred). Particularly within Europe, the parents are taking the kids to the periodic meetups with other families, so those kids are getting the same amount of exposure to the language within a community as city kids brought back to rural grandparents' house for holidays.


Replies

tgv • yesterday at 8:57 PM

Except there's no media in Esperanto that can compete with the dominant language. And there surely are other factors, such as that the parents are unlikely to be really fluent in most cases. Labeling it as native or L1 is following a loose definition strictly.

➕ show 2 replies