logoalt Hacker News

Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case

496 points • by ybathaee • yesterday at 1:18 AM • 219 comments • view on HN

Comments

SubiculumCode • yesterday at 6:11 AM

If they are price fixing, eff them.

Finally secure a research grant and had budgeted money for a new compute workstation and the RAM prices are killing my budget, because I'd love to get at least 256 GB of RAM and that's 4-5 grand now. Ridiculous, especially since I'd like to have a GPU in it with at least 32Gb of VRAM for medical image model training, so that is also like 4-5 grand too.

Do I wait two years and hope, or pay, isthe question I keep asking myself.

➕ show 10 replies
PeterStuer • yesterday at 9:05 AM

It's a 3 way prisoners dilemma market where the prisoners have been caught explicitly colluding before. Now they do not need explicit colluding anymore as the pattern and outcome has been established already and the "jail" is as good as closed to new entrants. Clearly the expected "market" is not working in this niche, so something will have to be done about it.

➕ show 3 replies
lpghatguy • yesterday at 3:31 PM

A machine-drafted AI news website should not be eligible for submission here.

➕ show 1 reply
burnte • yesterday at 10:31 PM

If these companies are innocent, they have the best lawyers money can buy and plenty of money to defend themselves. No one here needs to spend their limited time on Earth defending the actions of these corporations for free. nd if they're guilty you shouldn't defend them at all. So don't worry about it, let the corporations defend themselves, folks. The corporations will never, ever defend you.

sysguest • yesterday at 6:37 AM

idk going with DDR3/4/5 upgrades are really makes me doubt the whole argument...

those upgrades ARE ACTUAL UPGRADES, and if exiting ddr4 helps on producing more ddr5, why not?

(and the cheap chinese makers can produce plenty of those ddr4 chips, so it's NOT that "monopoly destroying the market" scenario)

➕ show 3 replies
bloomingeek • yesterday at 1:57 PM

Having read most of the posts for this subject, I got to thinking: wouldn't it be cool and beneficial to the HN community, if we tried to anticipate equipment price spikes? We tend to be electronic parts focused, so why not post trends as we see them.

Example: I, like I'm sure others did, saw the M.2 SSD prices starting to rise. Even though I didn't see the data center build up coming, I bought a small supply of SSDs. Unfortunately I didn't realize the future memory situation!

If this isn't cool with the Hacker News bylaws, I withdraw this idea :)

➕ show 4 replies
ketzu • yesterday at 9:15 AM

I am curious to see what will be uncovered in the trial. I know way too little of the market and tech involved to come to a conclusion (beyond anything motivated from wanting cheaper memory again).

Nearly everything could have a non-colluding explanation depending on the tech and market. (for example I would be skeptical to build up extremly expensive production if i follow the widespread belief that Ai is a huge bubble)

However, collusion is not magically out of the question with previous instances and some unexplained indicators. (which imo is what this dismissal means)

➕ show 2 replies
born-jre • yesterday at 9:36 AM

Not exactly related but I was thinking why don’t gov make rule like 40% of DRAM production has to be allocated for consumer electronics sectors but no AI regulation, wonder that would make compute distributed and no chicken and chicken man situation

➕ show 7 replies
bparsons • yesterday at 2:21 PM

I think there is a greater argument that points to hoarding of the global supply of these components by three or four cloud companies, which in turn forces consumers to rent their services.

dev1ycan • yesterday at 6:33 PM

It's the most obvious price fixing case in history

nullc • yesterday at 5:21 PM

I read the original complaint in this case when it was filed and I think it's a nothing burger. They admit outright that the reduction in supply is because the suppliers are making HBM instead, where they have infinite demand and are making more money.

Going after the memory suppliers is fashionable because they've gotten in trouble for collusion before-- but the claim's own text really undermines the collusion argument.

A more interesting question is probably: did large AI companies buy out the ram supply using their fountains of investor money in order to suppress competition in AI ... but that isn't a question that will be explored by this case.

shevy-java • yesterday at 9:17 AM

It's good that the courts finally look at the price fixing of the RAM cartel. I think it must become a much bigger lawsuit. It can not be that these de-facto monopolies keep on fixing the prices upwards. Even in a very capitalistic society such as the USA was once (before the orange mafia hijacked the country, even though in a more recent election the mafia lost big), capitalism assumes that free market competition lowers the prices and affordability for the average Joe, as a buyer. Clearly this is NOT the case here in the RAM cartel. You now pay like 3x as much as you did two or three years ago - and the high prices are maintained. That's a cartel. That has nothing to do with a free market.

I also think mandatory jail times for the CEOs need to happen. It can not be that they can buy their way out of punishments and damage they cause against society.

➕ show 3 replies
badgersnake • yesterday at 9:33 AM

Lock them up and throw away the key, ideally with the serial killers.

moribvndvs • yesterday at 5:36 AM

I swear if they are found guilty of price fixing 13 or 14 more times, I’m outta here.

➕ show 3 replies
Woodi • yesterday at 7:35 AM

New meme discovered ! :))

"more akin to hawks flying in formation – an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do"

Just strange nowhere in article DDR5 is mentioned...

ppierre • yesterday at 8:31 AM

The last scope of the ram cartel before the Chinese take the market. (Just my opinion.)

bagacrap • yesterday at 2:46 PM

Well apparently the last price fixing conviction was only made after Micron blew a whistle, so if they just keep their lips zipped they're probably good.

beloch • yesterday at 9:24 AM

If only they could be tried for ̶ ̶b̶r̶e̶a̶k̶i̶n̶g̶ reversing Moore's law.

taxmantakes • yesterday at 2:51 PM

They’ll fine the companies and that money goes back into the government coffers. Meanwhile the companies have to jack up prices to pay the fine. A win for everyone!

Shellban • yesterday at 6:39 PM

How wise of her.

bob1029 • yesterday at 9:31 AM

I think an investigation is fine but I also think they might actually have a reasonable defense with demand around HBM.

The way this is packaged seems to hinge on the expectation that there isn't some kind of AI revolution under way. Everyone just spontaneously decided to fuck over dram production and instead manufacture nearly impossible assemblies that yield like shit. The semiconductor industry. Famously risk adverse. I really don't buy it.

If the dram price went up and there wasnt something like HBM demand to explain it away, then perhaps we have something more serious to work with.

➕ show 1 reply
tenat10 • yesterday at 8:10 AM

Of course they did, in my opinion. They knew exactly what would happen. These people making choices arent morons. SK Hynix, Micron, Samsung all saw the opportunity as long as they are in sync. Then they all sit back raising MSRP with each other as "fake competition".

They could literally reopen manufacturing. But why? They know its free profit through inaction as long as none of them fix consumer DRAM market.

This act of playing dumb and ignorant has never been easier. Getting really old

➕ show 1 reply
phyzix5761 • yesterday at 8:23 AM

We may be witnessing the popping of the AI bubble. First with Jensen, then with this, and soon with Anthropic and OpenAI's failed IPOs.

➕ show 2 replies
andrewstuart • yesterday at 9:58 AM

“Look, we are so definitely absolutely not price fixing, so ummmm errrr well ……… no need for a court case!”

……… “denied”

amelius • yesterday at 11:10 AM

It's funny to see the biggest free market supporters now thinking that maybe they had it wrong.

➕ show 2 replies
mesm7903 • yesterday at 6:36 AM

If the claims hold up, this is a big deal for anyone building PCs or servers right now — RAM prices directly shape what people can afford to build.

➕ show 3 replies