logoalt Hacker News

A Perfect SimCity

203 points • by mariuz • last Sunday at 5:54 AM • 106 comments • view on HN

Comments

_whiteCaps_ • today at 3:42 PM

A SimCity fact I love to share:

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/05/the-p...

> Geoff Manaugh: While you were making those measurements of different real-world cities, did you discover any surprising patterns or spatial relationships?

> Librande: Yes, definitely. I think the biggest one was the parking lots. When I started measuring out our local grocery store, which I don't think of as being that big, I was blown away by how much more space was parking lot rather than actual store. That was kind of a problem, because we were originally just going to model real cities, but we quickly realized there were way too many parking lots in the real world and that our game was going to be really boring if it was proportional in terms of parking lots.

➕ show 2 replies
phaser • today at 1:53 PM

I love SimCity, but after a few hundred hours of playing (or at least the early ones) you can't ignore the fact that in order to build the "optimal" city you would need to create the counterintuitive things that are described here, like cities that are rail-only. Or the "perfect" rate of death by starving.

I often wonder if that's also an unintentional reflection coming from simulating real life, where there's sadly too many examples of people with enough power to attempt a "optimisation" that regards human life as purely a math game.

In the 1980s, Dictator Augusto Pinochet was questioned about missing persons by a journalist who points out coffins have been found with two, or three bodies in it, as to what he responds "What a great cost-saving!" [1]

Maybe half of the countries in the world had had an "optimiser" who was playing the SimCity score hacking with economic and social shocks that chase some sort of equilibrium for the "greater good" and just like in SimCity[2] the process leaned towards a dehumanising dystopia.

Maybe we have a group of "world-optimisers" running a country right now? Perhaps a big one?

While working on my own city builder [3] I've had the fortune to travel a lot to learn about what makes cities great, and my favourite cities are far from perfect, my personal feeling is that in a lot of aspects is quite the opposite: chaos, diversity, entropy, is what's intuitive about cities where people look free and happy, not order and perfect numbers.

1. https://es.wikiquote.org/wiki/Augusto_Pinochet

2. https://www.moma.org/interactives/exhibitions/2013/designand...

3. https://microlandia.city

➕ show 13 replies
alsetmusic • today at 6:39 PM

I don't remember where I learned this trick, but you can bulldoze houses and cheat by placing overlapping residential tiles to increase density.

monster_truck • today at 11:59 AM

Great post.

I have really fond childhood memories of learning every aspect of sc2k by reading through "SimCity 2000 - Power, Politics, And Planning, Revised Edition", actually figuring out how to build a city that would flourish was so rewarding.

➕ show 1 reply
t_e_s • today at 1:38 PM

This approach of reimplementing a game to understand it (in another post by author https://www.jeffquast.com/post/hamurabi_bas/) has been something I've really been enjoying recently.

I made a fantasy mobile variant of Mechabellum and smashed a lot of Chesterton's fences in the process - very educational.

➕ show 1 reply
waltbosz • today at 12:23 PM

The Super Nintendo version of Simcity was so much fun. I stayed up too late playing it many nights in my childhood. I was never great at it, figuring out the rules of simulation games didn't interest me, but I still had fun.

➕ show 1 reply
nico • today at 3:09 PM

Very interesting. Related, but on a tangent. Someone used something like REA to make a simcity 2k clone that runs on the browser and can load the original sc2 city files

https://city2026.app/play/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SimCity/s/6Nxc4XZZRK

maurits • today at 1:29 PM

Reminds me of simcity 3000 its legendary hellish Magnasanti [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NTJQTc-TqpU

PowerElectronix • today at 3:14 PM

That's what happens when you take a top-down approach to a bottom-up problem. People want to live in societies in order to live better lives. Being the manager of a big society and optimizing it, instead of the lives of the people, is what causes this degenerate strategies to win.

The man that wields the streadsheet sees everyone as a number.

lifefeed • today at 4:12 PM

I can't believe I remember this, but the land used for bigcity5 was my favorite land. I'd always build the mayors house on that island in the river.

thomasfl • today at 4:05 PM

More people should be involved in how real cities are planned and built. If only people working as developers in private real estate companies decides what to build, then that will eventually result in very bad places for everybody. Four years ago I started an NGO in Norway called the Architectural uprising. The real estate market and building industry is one giant clusterf*ck in Norway. It costs around 70% more to build housing here than across the border in Sweden. Tax cuts for people with great mortgage on their homes, have created a real estate bubble that sooner or later is going to burst. We simply don't get more of the types of cities needed for local businesses to grow, for people to spend less time wasting time stuck in traffic in private cars and places suited to raise kids. There's much more important, and frankly interesting, stuff to do than playing SimCity.

dfxm12 • today at 1:47 PM

I like that SC2K eschewed the scoring. The score is easy enough to ignore in SC, but its mere presence suggests that there is some specific way to win or lose. That SC2K doesn't even present a score suggests that the game is open ended and operates more on your terms.

➕ show 2 replies
hizlikovboy27 • today at 1:10 PM

This reminds me of the Atari games I used to play in my childhood. I would spend hours playing them.

manoDev • today at 3:33 PM

Looking at what is "optimal" makes it clear SimCity is just a game, and doesn't really attempt to model reality.

I wonder if realistic simulations have been attempted?

➕ show 2 replies
elfly • today at 2:22 PM

find weird that nobody has ported the snes extras to micropolis

robotmay • today at 1:16 PM

I went through a period of trying to "solve" traffic in Cities: Skylines a few years back. Ultimately I succeeded; by making the entire city a one-way spiral into the centre, where a bridge then took drivers back out to the start. It was perfect.

Later I decided to travel on-board with a citizen and realised that this was a form of torture, turning slightly left for around an hour. Want to go to a shop one block in the wrong direction? Tough shit - into the hell spiral.

Could be worse though, I could have modelled it on Oxford.

➕ show 3 replies
bovermyer • today at 12:35 PM

In my games of SimCity, the best cities were the ones that were on fire, exploding, stomped by not-Godzilla, or otherwise having a _very challenging day._

➕ show 1 reply
octocop • today at 12:47 PM

> what improves a city most is reducing available housing

So that is why housing is so expensive in cities

➕ show 1 reply
Kuyawa • today at 2:14 PM

"I found the best strategy is systemic starvation of 3% of the population"

WTF? I know politicians love this way of thinking but didn't know computer simulations would agree with them

➕ show 1 reply
feliksgorisek23 • today at 2:11 PM

I love SimCity. Back to the childhood again. :)

mock-possum • today at 4:57 PM

> When the number of jobs exceeds the residents zoned to fill them, The Unemployment term goes negative and adds to the score, providing a score bonus of about 128 points. No other term moves the score this much.

Interesting exploit!

teiferer • today at 4:56 PM

Sounds like a perfect task for an AI agent. Give them the source code, let them figure out what approach would maximize that metric, then let them play it. Alternatively, don't even give them the source code, just let them so trial and error.

Could even turn into a LLM benchmark of sorts.

TMWNN • today at 4:09 PM

I have long thought that all politicians should be required to play the original SimCity, Civilization, and M.U.L.E..

TheRealPomax • today at 3:05 PM

But why is the scroll-wheel behaviour for the graphics not respecting the fact that I'm on a desktop with boring old school normal mouse wheel behaviour, zooming the exact opposite from what it should be doing?

xXSLAYERXx • today at 2:12 PM

"skyway one reporting heavy traffic"

shevy-java • today at 1:16 PM

SimCity 1 was a great game. A shame that such games today have no real way to be made, save for some indie games.

➕ show 5 replies
tambourine_man • today at 1:47 PM

Now I’m singing its tune in my head

learntoplaypitc • today at 3:29 PM

[flagged]

toolbrewlab • today at 3:04 PM

[flagged]

bigsa_1 • today at 1:56 PM

[dead]