Serious whisky collector (and drinker) here...
You don't need a fancy glass. Your sense of smell makes a huge difference when it comes to food and drink, as anybody with a nasty cold can tell you. You want something that keeps it from diffusing into the air so anything with a wide mouth makes it harder to appreciate.
So: a cognac snifter; sherry glass; a glencairn, which was ""made for whisky""; etc.
But of course it's down to taste.
If the aroma is too heady? Blow air into glass and then inhale the aroma. The burn is gone (important if you're drinking 62% rocket fuel single cask whisky) and you get a more dilute smell.
No need for all this pretension; this glass is that.
I went to a very upscale members only whiskey tasting club in Edinburgh. Money was clearly spent. But nothing special about the glasses, and to add any water to open it up, just regular push button drinking fountains.
I did really get the impression that serious whiskey drinkers do not care for pretension.
Also a “serious drinker” here. I stopped caring about my whisky glass during my first trip to Scotland. Up until then, I would feel slightly offended to be served a good whisky in anything other than a glencairn or a copita. But throughout the trip (which involved mostly high end warehouse tastings), I noticed that nobody really cared about the glass. At each distillery I’d get a random glass (sometimes a copita, sometimes a glencairn, a lot of times something else) and, between drams, they would just direct us to tap water to clean our glasses. They cared about the whisky, not the container.
You don't, but sometimes the pretension is just part of the fun.
On the other hand, if you want to maximise pretension, drink from a quaich (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaich). Exceptionally ceremonial but it does nothing for the taste.
> No need for all this pretension
> a cognac snifter ... a glencairn
I think it's all relative.
I’ve been drinking whiskey seriously for several decades and been doing so out of one these [0] for most of that time. Having done many side-by-side taste tests with my friends over the years (I started with a pair of glasses, now down to one), we all agree the burn is noticeably less. Is it a double-blind experiment? No. Could placebo be in effect? Quite possibly. But I can only report what I’ve experienced - the burn is less.
[0]. https://theneatglass.com/product/the-artisan-neat-glass-2-pa...
I agree with all you said. Except... some whimsy might truly make people enjoy the thing more.
Like audiophile cables, the placebo effect contributes to the experience. Or maybe it’s the lack of nocebo that helps. Either way, someone convinced the whiskey tastes better from that glass will actually taste something better in their subjective experience.
Entire fashion business is just emotions for example. Dont underestimate that part of humans
You don’t need a fancy glass. However the glass does affect the taste and nose experience.
Have you ever tasted red wine from a proper wine glass next to a regular cup and noticed how the wine hits a different part of your pallet? How the thickness of the glass affects the experience? How the size and shape affects the aroma?
These are real things, none of which you need.
You don’t need audiophile speakers to listen to music, but if you’re an audiophile or even anyone with good hearing, your experience is going to be different with better speakers.
You don’t need a fancy pizza oven to make good pizza, but you can make better pizza - at least of certain kinds - with one.
You can be a “serious whiskey collector” and not care about the glass, just like you can be a serious fan of music and not care about the speakers, or a serious hiker and not care about your attire, or serious golfer and not care about your clubs or balls, etc etc.
Maybe more applicable here, you can be a great software developer and write in PHP.
I drink whiskey and wine from whatever glass is in close reach, however when that happens to be a proper glass, I definitely notice.
So please don’t cast your disdain on people who care about the nuances of their experience, no matter how nice your whiskey collection is.