Does his profit depend on actual properties of the glass or on his ability to convince buyers that the alleged difference is worth the price? Or that it's a fashionable status symbol for those who can afford it? After all, the glass would probably be wasted if you only drank cheap swill out of it.
It's multi-variable optimization, not either/or. You need to make the product good enough to get serious experts admitting that it has real virtues, and distinctive enough to boldly differentiate from your competitors while getting a good placebo effect, and play up the social status.
And notice the very long, thin stem in the picture? That'll maximize breakage, so your customers need to keep buying more glasses.