logoalt Hacker News

OroPla • yesterday at 11:15 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

AI being a bubble doesn't change that it is here to stay and thus there is a need for more RAM either way. There was a railway bubble in the 1840s, but it didn't lead to trains going away, either.


Replies

Grombobulous • yesterday at 6:35 PM

If you look at passenger rail maps of the United States, trains definitely went away.

Passenger rail versus freight rail also demonstrates how the railroad bubble and aftermath ended up proving that not every use of rail is inherently profitable. In the long term, passenger rail is rarely profitable and almost always has to be subsidized by the state in some way with only a handful of exceptions.

➕ show 1 reply
RunSet • yesterday at 4:05 PM

> AI being a bubble doesn't change that it is here to stay

Neither does its being here to stay does not mean it is good or desirable.

In any case "It is here to stay." does not resemble a falsifiable claim. If you were wrong how could you tell?

➕ show 1 reply
ketzu • yesterday at 11:37 AM

The point is that while AI might stay, that an AI bubble popping will massivelys reduce demand for RAM. So any production capacity you might have built up is not able to earn back its cost.

If you think demand will break down before you can get a return on your investemtn, you should not build.

If you think of a different aspect of "the AI bububle popping", where demand for RAM does not significantly decrease, that's fine of course. But RAM demand by AI going down massively seems to be a major part of what a lot of people imagine when they talk about the bubble going away.

➕ show 2 replies