logoalt Hacker News

woadwarrior01 • yesterday at 12:06 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

You might want to read the court docket attached at the bottom of the page. The plaintiffs present substantial circumstantial evidence, consistent with tacit collusion (which is not illegal). It's for the courts to investigate and decide if there was explicit collusion, which is illegal.


Replies

KlutzySofa • yesterday at 1:22 PM

Tacit collusion and just working within the same market can also look the same. I have no skin in the game (other than wanting prices to go down again), but there is also way too much emotion involved in the discussions about this because it is hurting our wallets.

- Cutting DRAM production in 2022 as a result of low prices/demand made sense if they didn't expect the market to recover as quickly as it did. A lot of the recovery is also likely caused by the start of the AI boom.

- The deals OpenAI made with SK Hynix and Samsung was a smart move by OpenAI where they drove up prices for everybody else while securing "cheap" supply themselves. I dont think its clear whether SK Hynix and Samsung came out ahead in that deal as the demand likely would have risen either way and it wouldn't have needed to go up by as much as it has now.

- Moving production to HBM also makes perfect sense when that is what the market demands and is willing to pay a premium for.

➕ show 3 replies
omgwtfbyobbq • yesterday at 4:14 PM

Tacit collusion is only legal in specific circumstances. If the companies involved seem to be acting against their own economic self interests, are communicating indirectly, or are collectively using some external mechanism (like realpage or whatever it was called) to set prices, it can be illegal.