I honestly don’t understand how can anyone conclude that. All 3 players have their entire inventory sold + reliable reports that their entire next year’s inventory sold.
If you really are thinking from a game theory perspective, in order for it to be the prisoner dilemma, they each need to benefit from lowering prices individually (to cheat). But given that demand outstrips supply so much, they each just lose if they lower price, regardless of what the other players do.
The analogy/classification works if you assume they engineered the scarcity through collusion. Then its "lower prices to win the market" vs "work together to artificially lower supply as a smoke screen to squeeze on prices."
The sense of scarcity factors into the ability to negotiate these contracts. Cooking the reports has a direct impact on contracts and does increase real demand.
> Judge Wise found that near-identical customer-vetting practices all three companies allegedly adopted in January 2026 "strongly support a plausible inference of conspiracy." She rejected the companies' "obvious and non-conspiratorial explanation" of booming AI demand, noting that the vetting began after the AI boom and the HBM pivot were underway.
Note, it's not just one thing, it's a combination of practices that make the collusion more likely explanation than otherwise
> All 3 players have their entire inventory sold + reliable reports that their entire next year’s inventory sold.
If they had started building new fabs earlier, they might have been able to sell even more inventory _and_ gotten back into the consumer market that they now neglect. Instead they've been way too slow to respond to demand or, in this case, purposefully didn't respond to demand.
They created the supply shortage by cutting their production, all 3 of them, at the same time. That's what is damning.