logoalt Hacker News

saltcured • yesterday at 6:25 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Their method is a photo detector driving the oscilloscope, right?

How can they assume the rise/fall slope in those plots is characterizing the driving electrical signal? Wouldn't a PWM driver be able to have much faster transitions and look more square than that at these time scales?

It makes me wonder if this is the response of the organic phosphors and the difference in apparent "depth" of the dip is really just a difference of duration, since the dips are very V-shaped, rather than bottoming out.

It is slightly odd that it has this paired rhythm, but I don't think you can assume it is "DC-dimming" rather than just PWM quanta that are being anti-alias filtered by the phosphors and measurement methodology.


Replies

Groxx • yesterday at 7:19 PM

Isn't it the other way around? They're claiming it's PWM, not DC dimming - DC dimming would be smooth, this isn't.

And tbh I don't think the PWM driver is particularly interesting, nor are they claiming to be measuring it. The display itself is flickering, which is what they're measuring and what the problem (for some) is.

➕ show 1 reply