logoalt Hacker News

empthought • yesterday at 6:36 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Can you be more specific about this?


Replies

jrootabega • today at 4:03 AM

I don't think specific is all that necessary. It's been major news that new exploits are being found more frequently and easily. The Emacs maintainers, for various reasons, will probably not be keeping up with whatever gets found. Web browsing is processing untrusted content.

iLemming • today at 12:09 AM

> Can you be more specific about this?

No, they can't. People like to play this kind of fear-mongering and "cybersecurity theater" without even questioning first the cybersec posture, network perimeter - vpn, firewall, malware protections, etc. Everything the article describes is perfectly possible even without Emacs. OSA layer on Mac been doing even weirder things for odd thirty years.

It's not like people giving Emacs root shell access. It's culturally fitting for HN - signaling caution is always socially safe. Nobody ever got criticized for saying "that sounds risky". But "I evaluated the risks and accepted the tradeoffs for my situation" is the actual, pragmatic engineering. Security is risk management, not risk elimination.