logoalt Hacker News

breakyerself • yesterday at 6:57 PM • 6 replies • view on HN

Any time this stuff comes up it's important to understand that this el Nino is occuring in the context of a global climate that is warmer than any time in the last 125,000 years. The risks inherent to weather and climate are growing all the time.


Replies

noosphr • yesterday at 11:15 PM

The link between El Nino and extreme weather is breaking down. The last El Nino caused an extremely wet summer in Australia despite a century of data pointing in the opposite direction.

The current one seems to be doing the same as the old one.

Climate is filled with non linearities and drawing straight lines from the past is a fools errant.

Least we forget the Sahara only turned into a desert when it got less sunshine.

stingraycharles • today at 12:09 AM

I’m here in the Philippines and they’re expecting temperatures up to 52 degrees Celsius, which is absolutely insane considering the humidity. Highest temperature so far was 51 degrees during El Niño 2018.

➕ show 2 replies
Loquebantur • yesterday at 9:18 PM

The important part to understand here is the childish reaction by major parts of the US populace to the outsize responsibility their country has for the catastrophic development of the global climate.

Instead of acknowledging the scientific facts and the ethical implications thereof, they engage in "catch me if you can"-tactics.

They let themselves be willfully utilized as a shield of ignorance against the financial restitution they owe. Not to speak of the implied loss of influence in the world economy after fossil fuels are phased out.

➕ show 5 replies
criddell • yesterday at 10:27 PM

Is it important? The globe is warming and it’s the new normal. Explaining it one more time isn’t going to make a difference.

Those of us who want to see CO2 reductions need to find solutions that don’t lead to inflation in the short term. It’s probably going to be a technological rather than policy solution.

neves • today at 1:05 AM

I'm always impressed how people can talk about El Niño without mentioning global warming and the nocive USA decisions to drill more oil and to leave Paris Agreement.

Every climate news should come with the footnote: it is due to CO2 in the atmosphere and USA is, by far, the greatest emmiter per Capita

9rx • yesterday at 8:40 PM

> The risks inherent to weather and climate are growing all the time.

Risk is subjective, so this doesn't mean much without quantifying what you feel is risky to you. Moreover, of all the risks we have heard expressed in the population, there is no unary growth value. There is a change in distribution, and some risks have grown, but some risks have also shrunk. If you are relying on the reader to bring their own idea of what the risks are, this is almost certainly going to be false.

I expect you say this with good intentions, trying to instil fear in the reader to convince them that climate change is something to pay attention to. But this kind of "absolute truth" that doesn't hold up to scrutiny is what actually turns people off paying attention to something that justifiably does warrant attention. Let's do better.

➕ show 4 replies