logoalt Hacker News

bitdivision • yesterday at 8:31 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

I don't believe a normal 'good' mechanic would be able to re-map it in 30 mins (assuming the underlying issue wasn't something else).


Replies

thisismyanon2 • today at 3:24 AM

There was an underlying issue and if the state and/or feds caught you remapping the ECU you'd get smacked down hard.

rpcope1 • today at 2:44 AM

It wasn't clear watching that video that a "remap" was remotely appropriate. A persistent +22% fuel trim, especially at a vehicle that age, is something like unmetered air, a stuck injector or dying fuel pump. Claude will confidently assert all sorts of absurd shit, when a normal mechanic would apply some common sense here. If you've never tried to setup a MegaSquirt, you have no idea how easy it is to screw up a fuel map and cause something like detonation. If anything, maybe you pull an ECM from a non-CARB XJ, but really a lean engine this age is going to be something way more pedestrian like cracked vacuum lines, a stuck injector, or this being an XJ, shitty wiring somewhere. At best I wonder if Claude is going to raise a new generation of parts changers.

schwap • yesterday at 10:21 PM

There almost certainly IS an underlying issue, though. Unless the ecu spontaneously recapped itself.