logoalt Hacker News

Loquebantur • yesterday at 10:14 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

You conflate wildly different metrics to paint a simply false overall picture.

The state of the climate is due to the accumulation of CO2 in Earth's atmosphere. You pretend, those past emissions didn't happen. Also, global emissions expanded dramatically over the last 25 years.

The U.S. share of global annual CO2 emissions "peaked" at roughly 55% in 1918 during the height of early American industrialization. Obviously, that's an absurd comparison to mention here. What matters is the overall contribution in actual metric tons.

U.S. emissions are not currently dropping without interruption. After falling roughly 18% to 20% from their 2005 - 2007 peak, U.S. emissions rebounded in 2025, increasing by 2.4% to 3.2% due to colder winter weather, rising electricity demand from data centers, and a 13% jump in coal-fired power generation.

The claim that emissions fell mainly due to "dematerialization" and free-market packaging efficiency is largely inaccurate. While economic efficiency played a supporting role, energy sector transitions were the dominant driver. The reductions were driven primarily by replacing coal with natural gas and renewables in the power sector.

And that's all completely ignoring the systemic influence the US has had and still has.