logoalt Hacker News

chrisvls • yesterday at 10:23 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

I’m a little frustrated with talking about birds as a class in this context. Crows are legendary for figuring things out.

Turkeys are also legendary. Like the farmer brings three of them out, chops the head of the first one off. The other two are still standing there. “Wow! Look what happened to Charley! I wonder what this line is for.”

“Birdbrain” may be wrong for corvids but too complimentary to turkeys.


Replies

adjejmxbdjdn • today at 12:30 AM

Your turkey case necessitates beings that have been subjected to captivity and horrors all their lives.

There is almost nothing to learn about their natural instincts and behaviors from what is done to farmed animals.

We also see this with cows where we saw a cow use a tool earlier this year, and it’s obvious the only reason we thought they were incapable was because cows are completely domesticated at this point and there is no opportunity for them to do so.

jyounker • yesterday at 10:55 PM

Domestic turkeys were bred to be stupid. Wild turkeys are smart. They have large vocabularie, and complicated social structures.

singingfish • yesterday at 11:09 PM

I view it as more fundamental than that. Size for size, joule for joule and cm3 for cm3 a smart bird seems to get a lot more out of their brain than smart mammals. I big chunk of the determinant of intelligence is diet quality, which is why horses, cows koalas are so dumb and why koalas are so sleepy.

analog31 • today at 12:29 AM

Living in a town with a sizable turkey population, they're also utterly oblivious to car traffic when they're in the middle of the road. It's interesting that they're smart about some things, and stupid about others.

taneq • today at 12:34 AM

Doves, too. I’m convinced that doves lie, on the spectrum of intelligence, somewhere between bananas and sea slugs.