logoalt Hacker News

TeMPOraL • yesterday at 10:31 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Second version is clearer standalone, but the original quote is the last paragraph of an article that built up the very concepts that look "unclear" when that quote is posted standalone.

FWIW, I don't see any special nuance here. The phrasing is just being precise, and addresses specifically the concepts it introduced earlier.

(Also the "clearer" version is slightly inaccurate rendition of the quote - the original one doesn't imply that the models don't know most tests aren't alignment evals. The article gives more context here - the models may or may not know that, they just don't act as if they cared about it in the first place - i.e. they don't display "Eval Awareness" in their behavior.)


Replies

coldtea • today at 12:06 AM

>Second version is clearer standalone, but the original quote is the last paragraph of an article that built up the very concepts that look "unclear" when that quote is posted standalone.

Another way to see it, would be that "the second version is clearer standalone, but would look out of place in the article, which uses overly noisy language throughout, and could really use a total rewriting in the style of the second version".

"The article gives more context here - the models may or may not know that, they just don't act as if they cared about it in the first place - i.e. they don't display "Eval Awareness" in their behavior."

Your correction here shows how easy it would be to fix the inaccuracy in the second quote, while still staying in plain language...