logoalt Hacker News

helterskelter2 • yesterday at 11:04 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

This comment reminds me: I was in a used bookstore a few weeks ago with my dad (a retired engineer) and he bought up a bunch of the old math and engineering books because, he said, they approach their subjects differently and explain how things work, they walk you through the math and work to build up a detailed mental model of what's actually happening. His feeling was that modern textbooks make everything so abstract that the subject begins to feel divorced from what you're trying to do or understand, which makes getting an intuitive grasp on a topic really difficult.

He showed me some of the books from the 40's and 50's geared towards teens and honestly they did a better job of explaining things than the college textbooks I had to use -- they didn't go into fine detail, but they gave you a good framework to build on and a way of thinking about something which I feel is lacking from contemporary texts.

Tangentially, Feynman said something in a similar vein about the transition from analogue to digital. Kids couldn't tinker anymore and had no real impetus to learn some of the laws which underpin their workings, and most importantly, had no way to build an intuition around these laws through casual experimentation (i.e. fixing a broken radio with a handful of parts from Radio Shack).

Abstraction can be a very powerful tool, but growing up and learning in an environment which has these abstractions already built-in is a real handicap to building a deep understanding of a subject. You become dependent on the tools themselves instead of developing the knowledge used to build the tools -- in effect, the tools become limitations. Look at kids who grew up with iPhones instead of Amigas, or people already becoming dependent on LLM's.


Replies

annzabelle • yesterday at 11:18 PM

There's a book called "Quick Calculus" (originally published in 1965, though I have the 1991 second edition) that my high school physics teacher gave me as a way to prep for physics class over the summer. It's a self teaching guide to basic calculus and is written to be used standalone without a lecture or grader. It has choose your own adventure stuff where if you get a question right you can skip over an extra explanation/example.

I've kept it around and used it for self teaching when I went down the rabbit hole of prepping for actuarial exams a year back, and again for prepping for going back to college to change careers to medical physics (yes, I have been looking at a bunch of different options to leave software).

I find it so much more elegant and straightforward than modern textbooks, and it's so much easier to focus on pen and paper vs screens. I've had people suggest Khan Academy and 3Blue1Brown, but I find I learn more deeply and retain better from a good old school textbook.

breezybottom • today at 3:17 AM

[dead]