logoalt Hacker News

bob1029 • yesterday at 11:12 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

I think the only reason we can actually do things like dancing and playing of pianos is because our brains are capable of predicting the future. Maybe not very far but far enough to compensate for the end to end latency. I don't think you train your spine when you learn an instrument. I think you learn a predictive model of the world that allows you to anticipate events far enough in advance to execute correctly.


Replies

lukan • today at 12:03 AM

The head is too far away from all the limbs to directly control every movement, the nerve cells in the body are basically like mini brains all over, so yes, you do train your spine when you learn any physical activity. And my pet theory why some really have trouble learning dancing etc. is exactly because they try to control every movement with their brain, but this doesn't really work (I know I initially tried to learn dancing and instruments like this and that caused frustration). The fingers should learn to play automatically. So this does of course has to be in coordination with the brain and the brain needs a predictive model of the future to do the coordination right and this is also what learning means, adapting that model, but the brain cannot directly control every finger and get the timing right. The learning also happens in the nerve cells in the body, not just the brain.

➕ show 1 reply
seba_dos1 • today at 2:02 AM

Yes, and you can exploit that to play music online in real time with tools like Jamulus. The trick is to set it up to only hear yourself after the network roundtrip, so you can get in sync with other players - initially it feels very off, but once the brain adjusts for latency you can even forget it's there.

WalterBright • yesterday at 11:32 PM

> I don't think you train your spine when you learn an instrument.

I saw an article about it years ago.